Pear
The teardrop
VS
Marquise
Maximum spread per carat
Pear vs Marquise
The two pointed, elongated shapes. Both stretch the finger and the dollar; they differ in symmetry and drama.
Best for wearable drama: PearBest for face-up size: Marquise
| Pear | Marquise | |
|---|---|---|
| Silhouette | Teardrop: one rounded end, one point | Boat-shaped: points at both ends |
| Face-up size | Large for its weight | Among the largest face-up looks of any shape |
| On the hand | Elongating, slightly softer presence | Maximum lengthening effect; unmistakable |
| Watch for | Bow-tie, and the point needs a protective prong | Bow-tie, plus two points to protect |
| Price per carat | Well below round | Well below round |
| Styling quirk | Worn point-up or point-down; her call | Polarizing in the best way; people love it or do not |
Pick pear if
- She wants distinctive without going full vintage
- A softer, asymmetric line appeals to her
- One protected point feels like enough risk
Pick marquise if
- The biggest possible look per carat is the brief
- Her style runs bold and she enjoys a statement
- You have seen her admire one; this shape is rarely a lucky guess
Do not guess with these two
Round and oval survive guessing; pear and marquise do not. These are personality shapes, adored by the people who adore them. Confirm through her saved photos, her friends, or her own words before buying either.
Both need good settings
Points chip when struck, so both shapes want V-prongs over every point and a competent setter behind them. Budget a little extra attention for the setting and both wear beautifully for decades.